As far as the recent collapse, Mr. Allison identified four themes that influenced the actions of government and banks.
(1) Government policy of fixing problems through increased regulation and control - a mixed regulated economy that has become increasingly regulated in recent decades
(2) Policies creating a bubble in the real estate market
(3) Refusal to let businesses fail
(4) Doing anything for short term gain at the expensive of long term strength and stability
Mr. Allison identified the Federal Reserve and the broad regulatory system as the primary problem in the crisis. Since the monetary system was nationalized in 1913, the market has had less and less control over the dollar. In his opinion, the idea of integrating the economic activity of seven billion people worldwide is not sustainable or feasible. The Fed is not able to fix prices and avoid a crisis for a long period of time. Negative margins and inverse ratios in the market led to bad loans and increased risk. Identified as "the proximate cause" of the crisis, the government's housing policy and the belief that simply owning a home was a goo in itself led to huge problems. Personal incentives to be frugal, have discipline, and buy within one's means were lost in this fervor. Both conservatives and liberals recognized the lack of sustainability of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae. Intelligent legislators ignored the high leverage ratios and the increasing debt the housing policy would inevitably cause in the market. Mr. Allison identfied Barnie Frank as an example of an intelligent legislator who understood the risk, but ignored based on a "religious" devotion to housing for all.
Furthermore, Mr. Allison identified President Lyndon Johnson's administration and the Great Society as pivotal historical point after the New Deal, but before Fannie & Freddie, that led to this system. LBJ wanted to fund the Vietnam War and the vast expansion of the welfare state, but did not want to do the politically unpopular thing, raise taxes on the American people. Thus, the programs were funded by printing money under the watch of The Federal Reserve and the Treasury. Professor Allison pointed to this decisions is a harbinger of the increased regulation of the monetary system, mortgage rates, and the real estate market. Once the government was in the market, private companies were unable to compete with their rates and guarantees. Since the purpose of banks is to enable people to invest for longer periods of time by buying short and selling long. The Fed, the Treasury, and the FDIC's policies and intervention led to increased leverage ratios and unfair playing field. In the face of this controlled market, led to banks and accountants to make unnatural market decisions.
Moreover, Mr. Allison rejected that greed and avarice is a primary cause the collapse. He acknowledged that Wall Street is greedy, but not more so than at any other point in history. Policy and government regulation, he argued, is the true problem despite the political points won by attacking the wealthy on Wall Street. Mr. Allison also rejected the idea of "too big to fail." He points to AIG as an example of a huge and successful firm that might seem too big to fail, but that in reality was only one firm in the grand scheme of the system. In a more controversial point, Mr. Allison suggested that AIG's connections to Goldman Sachs, which has large personnel and financial connections to the FDIC, was a major basis for the FDIC's view that AIG was an irreplaceable player in the market. He added that BB&T would have been fine without AIG. Finally, Mr. Allison defended BB&T's acceptance of TARP funds despite his personal opposite to the program. The Fed and chairman Ben Bernanke's decision to change the credit ratio and effectively force all major banks to accept the funds left him with no choice in the matter. However, he wanted to emphasize BB&T paid back all loans with interest.
In the closing portion of his speech, Mr. Allison turned to philosophy and his vision of how to approach life and politics. He ejected John Maynard Keynes economic philosophy of "digging holes and filling them up" to arbitrarily keep the market moving. In lieu of Keynesianism, the government should keep taxes low and deregulate to allow producers to create jobs and invest in the market. Mr. Allison argued that not wealthy people are productive, but in general when taxes are lower the wealthy is more active in the market and increases overall investment. From a political standpoint, Mr. Allison advocated for reduced scale of government, lower taxes, free trade, a reduction in regulation and public companies.
On a personal level, Mr. Allison advocated three major points. First, pure altruism leads to redistribution of wealth and turns the nation into a society of unproductive parasites. Since each person has a right to his own life, Americans should return to the Jeffersonian vision of freedom of the individual to pursue his own life and interests. Second, the devotion to pragmatism can lead to short term gains at the expense of long term virtue and strength. Abandoning virtue and compromising for security and short term protection will not work in the long run. The best personal approach is pursuing long-terms self-interest under the "trader principle." This approach rewards rationality and self-discipline and results in long term success. Finally, the "free lunch" mentality is not sustainable or a path to a successful life. Mr. Allison reminds us that neither Presidential candidate in the 2008 Election proposed any tenable or serious solution to the welfare or medicare system.
Mr. Allison encouraged the students in the audience to follow his three great values: Purpose, Reason, and Self-esteem. Self-esteem, he argues, comes from an earned life and work that leads to a sustained joy. Short-term security is not a substitute for life on one's own terms. The speech received a standing ovation from the crowd of nearly 400 students, attorneys, and scholars. (For further reading on Mr. Allison's philosophical approach, see the works of Adam Smith, Ayn Rand, or Tara Smith.)